30 million student-loan borrowers get bad news after a Trump-appointed federal judge officially blocks Biden from carrying out broader debt cancellation
30 million student-loan borrowers get bad news after a Trump-appointed federal judge officially blocks Biden from carrying out broader debt cancellation
The legal whiplash continues for millions of student-loan borrowers.
On Thursday, Judge Matthew Schelp of the Eastern District of Missouri, who was appointed by former President Donald Trump, placed a preliminary injunction on President Joe Biden’s plan to cancel student debt under the Higher Education Act of 1965.
This ruling came just hours after it appeared a separate federal court may have granted borrowers a lifeline. After a group of GOP state attorneys general filed a lawsuit in Georgia in September to block the debt relief, a federal judge ruled that Georgia was the improper venue for the lawsuit and transferred the case to Missouri.
Schelp’s ruling comes on the final day of the relief’s temporary restraining order — had Schelp not moved ahead and placed a preliminary injunction on the relief, the restraining order would have expired, and Biden would have been permitted to move forward with implementing the relief.
therapistofcats on
They vote against a bipartisan immigration reform bill, the vote against funds for FEMA, and now their activist judges inject their unelected selves into blocking relief for millions of Americans.
Why does the GOP hate Americans so much?
ianjm on
I think maybe the judicial branch needs a root and branch.
chillywanton on
I truly hope those affected who are of voting age remember who has been fighting to take this away from you. VOTE BLUE DOWN THE LINE.
ThomasJCarcetti on
These courts have really hampered a lot of the shit Biden has tried to get done
StubbornNobody on
This is garbage. Just let us have our relief. I’ll never be able to pay it back anyway due to circumstances outside of my control. Honestly I would if I could. What do they stand to gain from blocking this?
Huckleberry-V on
I know this is a bit of a liberal echo chamber but good. Debt forgiveness is asking our children to cover the tab for our education. It’s the same shit the boomers did with social security playing out again. “Just exempt ourselves”.
seekAr on
I just want to be fucking happy and productive in my society and not always have algorithms and sociopaths in power fucking with my freedom. Why can’t they just be fucking nice?
JayMan2224 on
“You see, Kamala stops everything! She can’t do her job” – Republicans
thistimelineisweird on
Vote for Harris and give her a Congress that can make this the law of the land.
Marxian_factotum on
Education and health care are both human rights. Neither educational debt nor medical debt should exist at all. All of it should be summarily wiped out. The mere fact that this is configured as an undischargeable commodity in late stage capitalism is grotesque.
autotldr on
This is the best tl;dr I could make, [original](https://www.businessinsider.com/student-loan-forgiveness-blocked-biden-debt-cancellation-education-department-relief-2024-10) reduced by 72%. (I’m a bot)
*****
> Schelp's ruling comes on the final day of the relief's temporary restraining order – had Schelp not moved ahead and placed a preliminary injunction on the relief, the restraining order would have expired, and Biden would have been permitted to move forward with implementing the relief.
> The Education Department had previously intended to begin canceling student debt in October, and it has yet to post the final rule for the relief.
> With the latest ruling, Schelp wrote that the Education Department is enjoined from "Mass canceling student loans, forgiving any principal or interest, not charging borrowers accrued interest, or further implementing any other actions under the Rule or instructing federal contractors to take such actions.”
This whole ability to game the system by “judge shopping” really is an indicator to how broken the current federal court system is. Something needs to change so national injunctions can’t happen just because you file in a favorable jurisdiction. A national block should have to involve a group of national judges, not a single district court judge in a random state.
IJustWantFriends2024 on
Trump and his supporters are synonymous with wanting to fuck the kids at this point
Razielslipknot on
Biden should just do it anyway, I really don’t understand letting rogue judges make bad and politically based decisions that hurt millions.
probabletrump on
Okay, hear me out. A judge said it would be illegal for Biden to pay off these student loans. What if he made it an official act?
Random_frankqito on
Reform the loan processes. Please! Then actions like “loan forgiveness” won’t be necessary. If you can’t change the predatory loans then it’ll continue.
Javasndphotoclicks on
The Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program is a United States government program that was created under the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007 signed into law by President George W.
They’ve been fucking people over with this program for almost 20 years. Biden is just trying to make things right.
ericv2322 on
Republicans, and especially MAGAt Republicans, are a cancer in our society and they need to be excised. Get your asses out there and vote for the change you want. No excuses. VOTE.
Frustratedtx on
It’s actually a fucking ridiculous system that it only takes one unelected federal district court judge to block federal agencies from carrying out their duties across the entire country.
This same shit happened to the non-compete ban. Conservative judges are such douchebags.
David_Writes_Cozies on
Why the bloody fuck would someone do this?!
motohaas on
This is what we can expect from the republican party
rupertLumpkinsBrothr on
Can’t wait to vote in November.
BeldarRoundhead on
I was fortunate enough to have the government pay for most of my college but even if I didn’t college was basically FREE when I was in school (mid 90s) compared to now.
bramletabercrombe on
probably for the best. All that money they save will probably go into some tax free Cayman Island account or corporate stock buybacks.
HooninAintEZ on
So the trump judges were just playing hot potato
agentchris0011 on
Vote.
N_Who on
Always remember, Conservative voters: The Republican party’s primary goal is to keep the vast majority of Americans (including you!) poor, desperate, and locked into a system of modern feudalism.
They don’t want a better, smarter, healthier, more capable country. They want a small ruling class and a massive servant class and you are voting in favor of that every time you vote for them.
purplepop5 on
Duh.
Hrmbee on
Those 30 million people better all be voting in the coming elections.
jertheman43 on
That shouldn’t have any effect on the election. /s
AstralStrudel on
This was the one non-election related piece of good news I saw the other day, and a fucking dirty judge blocks it. Screw that judge. I need to stay off my phone for a while.
dam_sharks_mother on
Legal contracts bind both parties to the contract, news at 11.
People who actively pursue loans, enjoy the benefits of those loans, and now want to dine-and-dash when the check comes and make the server and busboy carry the bill? NAH. Pay your debts.
DrunkLifeguard on
Lmao, still not paying.
FUCK_THE_STORMCLOAKS on
Fuck it. Adjust the current repayment plans so that monthly payments are $50.
valamaladroit on
Just ignore the court and do it anyway. That’s what republicans in Texas are doing: a court there ruled they can’t deny trans folks gender changes on their documents, and they’re ignoring the court. So court rulings only matter if the judge is republican? I’m tired of this shit. Stop trying to work with a party that has zero interest in democracy.
36 Comments
The legal whiplash continues for millions of student-loan borrowers.
On Thursday, Judge Matthew Schelp of the Eastern District of Missouri, who was appointed by former President Donald Trump, placed a preliminary injunction on President Joe Biden’s plan to cancel student debt under the Higher Education Act of 1965.
This ruling came just hours after it appeared a separate federal court may have granted borrowers a lifeline. After a group of GOP state attorneys general filed a lawsuit in Georgia in September to block the debt relief, a federal judge ruled that Georgia was the improper venue for the lawsuit and transferred the case to Missouri.
Schelp’s ruling comes on the final day of the relief’s temporary restraining order — had Schelp not moved ahead and placed a preliminary injunction on the relief, the restraining order would have expired, and Biden would have been permitted to move forward with implementing the relief.
They vote against a bipartisan immigration reform bill, the vote against funds for FEMA, and now their activist judges inject their unelected selves into blocking relief for millions of Americans.
Why does the GOP hate Americans so much?
I think maybe the judicial branch needs a root and branch.
I truly hope those affected who are of voting age remember who has been fighting to take this away from you. VOTE BLUE DOWN THE LINE.
These courts have really hampered a lot of the shit Biden has tried to get done
This is garbage. Just let us have our relief. I’ll never be able to pay it back anyway due to circumstances outside of my control. Honestly I would if I could. What do they stand to gain from blocking this?
I know this is a bit of a liberal echo chamber but good. Debt forgiveness is asking our children to cover the tab for our education. It’s the same shit the boomers did with social security playing out again. “Just exempt ourselves”.
I just want to be fucking happy and productive in my society and not always have algorithms and sociopaths in power fucking with my freedom. Why can’t they just be fucking nice?
“You see, Kamala stops everything! She can’t do her job” – Republicans
Vote for Harris and give her a Congress that can make this the law of the land.
Education and health care are both human rights. Neither educational debt nor medical debt should exist at all. All of it should be summarily wiped out. The mere fact that this is configured as an undischargeable commodity in late stage capitalism is grotesque.
This is the best tl;dr I could make, [original](https://www.businessinsider.com/student-loan-forgiveness-blocked-biden-debt-cancellation-education-department-relief-2024-10) reduced by 72%. (I’m a bot)
*****
> Schelp's ruling comes on the final day of the relief's temporary restraining order – had Schelp not moved ahead and placed a preliminary injunction on the relief, the restraining order would have expired, and Biden would have been permitted to move forward with implementing the relief.
> The Education Department had previously intended to begin canceling student debt in October, and it has yet to post the final rule for the relief.
> With the latest ruling, Schelp wrote that the Education Department is enjoined from "Mass canceling student loans, forgiving any principal or interest, not charging borrowers accrued interest, or further implementing any other actions under the Rule or instructing federal contractors to take such actions.”
*****
[**Extended Summary**](http://np.reddit.com/r/autotldr/comments/1fwedcl/30_million_studentloan_borrowers_get_bad_news/) | [FAQ](http://np.reddit.com/r/autotldr/comments/31b9fm/faq_autotldr_bot/ “Version 2.02, ~694678 tl;drs so far.”) | [Feedback](http://np.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%23autotldr “PM’s and comments are monitored, constructive feedback is welcome.”) | *Top* *keywords*: **relief**^#1 **rule**^#2 **debt**^#3 **Education**^#4 **student**^#5
This whole ability to game the system by “judge shopping” really is an indicator to how broken the current federal court system is. Something needs to change so national injunctions can’t happen just because you file in a favorable jurisdiction. A national block should have to involve a group of national judges, not a single district court judge in a random state.
Trump and his supporters are synonymous with wanting to fuck the kids at this point
Biden should just do it anyway, I really don’t understand letting rogue judges make bad and politically based decisions that hurt millions.
Okay, hear me out. A judge said it would be illegal for Biden to pay off these student loans. What if he made it an official act?
Reform the loan processes. Please! Then actions like “loan forgiveness” won’t be necessary. If you can’t change the predatory loans then it’ll continue.
The Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program is a United States government program that was created under the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007 signed into law by President George W.
They’ve been fucking people over with this program for almost 20 years. Biden is just trying to make things right.
Republicans, and especially MAGAt Republicans, are a cancer in our society and they need to be excised. Get your asses out there and vote for the change you want. No excuses. VOTE.
It’s actually a fucking ridiculous system that it only takes one unelected federal district court judge to block federal agencies from carrying out their duties across the entire country.
This same shit happened to the non-compete ban. Conservative judges are such douchebags.
Why the bloody fuck would someone do this?!
This is what we can expect from the republican party
Can’t wait to vote in November.
I was fortunate enough to have the government pay for most of my college but even if I didn’t college was basically FREE when I was in school (mid 90s) compared to now.
probably for the best. All that money they save will probably go into some tax free Cayman Island account or corporate stock buybacks.
So the trump judges were just playing hot potato
Vote.
Always remember, Conservative voters: The Republican party’s primary goal is to keep the vast majority of Americans (including you!) poor, desperate, and locked into a system of modern feudalism.
They don’t want a better, smarter, healthier, more capable country. They want a small ruling class and a massive servant class and you are voting in favor of that every time you vote for them.
Duh.
Those 30 million people better all be voting in the coming elections.
That shouldn’t have any effect on the election. /s
This was the one non-election related piece of good news I saw the other day, and a fucking dirty judge blocks it. Screw that judge. I need to stay off my phone for a while.
Legal contracts bind both parties to the contract, news at 11.
People who actively pursue loans, enjoy the benefits of those loans, and now want to dine-and-dash when the check comes and make the server and busboy carry the bill? NAH. Pay your debts.
Lmao, still not paying.
Fuck it. Adjust the current repayment plans so that monthly payments are $50.
Just ignore the court and do it anyway. That’s what republicans in Texas are doing: a court there ruled they can’t deny trans folks gender changes on their documents, and they’re ignoring the court. So court rulings only matter if the judge is republican? I’m tired of this shit. Stop trying to work with a party that has zero interest in democracy.